Crystal's Story Site
· Return to Story Index Page · Add your Comments ·

Story Comments by Readers

Annie's Birthday
by Sarah Bayen

Latest comments are shown at top of page.


Comment by pron best on 05/13/17
s8JZpz sharing. my web page english bulldog puppies

Comment by Davina on 01/22/13
A lovely story beautifully written, although I do tend to agree with Jezzi Steven's suggestion that if the genders were reversed there could have been legal action.

If Stuart had perhaps tried to take legal action he would have suffered severe embarrassment.  How many of us would have had the nerve to face cross-examination in the courts?


Comment by Bev on 07/09/12
RobGreat shots   love the light on the couple in the chucrh and really love the moment that you captured during the speech   the bride looks as though she is about to burst!  Great emotion all the way through and such a happy, smiley couple!

Comment by Silvia. on 06/17/12
Disgusting, horrible, ridiculous, sickly,revolting,etc...

Comment by speedy on 03/21/12
Sarha love your writing. Story line is good, as always. Character development is outsanding. You draw a pitchure, with words, good enuogh for my imagination to the rest. Thank You  

Comment by Jo-Anne on 12/20/09
Also a 2nd read, and I agree with Jezzi. It's well written, as is usual for Sarah, but it's unadulterated cruelty and bullying of a weaker individual into submission.

Sarah is very proficient in role-reversal stories and this short one is no exception. I generally like Sarah's writing, for I think her stories are well written and mostly real sweet, and I am rather sad she apparently lost her zest for writing. Or maybe she's no longer able to write, that would be even more sad. On a personal level for her foremost.


Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 02/27/09
I just reread this and the comments. I can't believe the positive comments about what those female bullies did to Stuart, who did absolutely nothing to deserve such treatmant. I repeat my earlier comment, Think if the situation was reversed and a group of boys did the same things to a younger girl. Talk about a double standard here! Mean girls, VERY mean girls, particularly Annie, who is taking out her disgust with herself for liking a younger boy and revealing that liking to her friends on Stuart. The story is well written, as is usual for sarah, but it sure points out that bullies can be girls - and the comments indicate that most readers feel that girl bullying is OK.

Comment by juliej on 03/02/08
2nd reading brilliant more please i wish that you would have explained it more bur a brilliant  story it would have been great to for them to force hime dressed brilliant more please

Comment by juliej on 01/06/07
I would have loved to have been stuart a brilliant story i would like to have read how  they got hold of him at first and whether he struggled or not also if another story like this is done ie for another of the girls birthdays it would be great for a better decription of the knickers 7clothing etc also how they managed to get him a brilliant story more please again i wish it was me that this happend to brilliant

Comment by Impressed on 01/02/05
Wow. I have to say this is the greatest story on this site that I have ever read. Most other stories like this have are kind of easy to predict. In any case, keep up the good work! I'd love to read more stories of the same style

Comment by Jill on 12/15/04
I would love to have been Stuart, there is not better way to make a boy feel good in female attire than to make him enjoy himself. Sally/Stuart liked his new atttire as he did not get naked. I htink this story could have a sequal with sally being made to date a boy on the boys birthday.

Comment by julie j on 11/07/04
wonderfull story what a great way to have a birthday  present i would have really enjoyed that to be forced by five girls and forcibly dressed great story more please well  written & described right down to the colour of the panties they forced on him 2 pairs what a way to go

Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 11/01/04
In regard to Lesley's comment (since she did not opt for e-mail):  "all just harmless amusement for some wickedly dominant young ladies as far as I can see. "

If Stuart and a group of boys had done something similar to annie, do you think she would have considered it "harmless amusement"?  Society and the law wouldn't have.  If boys had done this to a girl, and were caught, they would be at the very least expelled and very likely in jail.

Comment by fregen on 08/18/04
Perhaps not the typical sweet and sentimental story but I hardly think Stuart will be traumatized by the incident.  He likes the fact that Annie thinks he is 'a dish.'  He considers Annie to be the best looking girl in the school.  He's rather turned on by her attentions.  

No the only fault I can find in the story is that, outside of the kiss at the end, he was excluded from any physical contact with Annie.  A snog and a snuggle might have put him in a much more comfortable state of mind.  And, keeping in mind the wink she gave him at the very end of the story, I am not so sure Annie is inclined to share him.  

Thanks Sarah.  Keep the stories coming!

Comment by Annabel on 08/05/04
Dear Sarah
I loved this story.  It's believable and sexy and your characters are really good, as always.
I always look forward to new stories from you.  You are my favourite writer on this site.  Please don't be put off by negatve comments and keep writing.
Hugs, Annabel

Comment by LESLEY on 08/05/04
Excellent story. Very well written and very sexy in places. The boy's embarassment and humiliation are depicted very well, as is the excitement of the girls at having him petticoated and at their mercy. I'm surprised at some of the readers' comments, all just harmless amusement for some wickedly dominant young ladies as far as I can see. I hope there will be follow-up in a similar vein, there is plenty of scope for one.

Comment by Jimmy on 08/04/04
A bit of a disappointment.

Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 08/04/04
I have always wondered how the keywords "physically forced or blackmailed" and "sweet and sentimental" can be used together.  Now I know; it was sweet and sentimental for Annie, certainly not for Stuart.  WOW, what a bitch Annie turned out to be, and her friends too, to a person who had never done anything to deserve that kind of treatment.  Another story that makes women look bad.  I hope Stuart gets a chance to turn the tables on those amoral bitches.   I guess after two EXCELLENT stories where the hero(ine) comes out a stronger person and doesa sort of turn the tables on "her" feminizers you felt the need to write a story where the females retain the upper hand.

Comment by Jane Hudson on 08/04/04
Stu my boy are you in trouble now.Love this story

Comment by jami on 08/04/04
Thank you Sarah, I enjoyed it. I could feel Stuart's humiliation and excitement, watching the girl he adores play with herself. It would seem that poor Stuart is trapped and will have to obey the girls. I am guessing there are no more chapters, so its fun to imagine what will happen next.

Comment by Sissy Baby Paula on 08/04/04
I did like the story. But sweet and sentimental? I would say not!

It's pure blackmail which could turn sour. I mean most propably Stuart would react at least unconciously and his parents would find out. Or he might simply tell his parents or even the headmaster. He has a lot to loose, but if the girls would keep him appearing for their fun as a girl he would propably think that anything is better than that. So the ending in my opinion was a bit cruel. Nobody wants to be a price delivered around.

The best part was why everything happened simply because of what Annie had said. That sure was a new reason to humilate a poor boy. I hoped that the story would have included more fun for Stuart (a little bit of very embarrassing excitement hardly counts).

Writing altogether is nice and perhaps if it is continued Stuart could either become a stronger person or have some fun beeing a female (the girls not just playing with him I hope).

Hugs from Sissy Baby Paula and Snowball

Comment by Pippa K. on 08/04/04
I enjoyed the story.  The weakest part, which I felt could have been the strongest part, was the "tossing off".  A little more sensuous development, a blush here, a hesitance there, some shared heavy breathing, could have improved it immensely and dampened a good few panties.

Comment by Tina on 08/04/04
Cute story!  Loved the way you wrote about Stuart's feelings of confusion, helplessness, and guilty pleasure.  Would perhaps have liked a bit more explanation as to why Annie got quite so excited while foisting her eyes on his knickers ~ was it a control thing or do the girls do this together?  Maybe that will come in part 2.  

Anyway, thanks as always for sharing this story with us.  

Tina xx



Add your Comments

      The importance of reader feedback cannot be overstated.   Authors rely on it to improve their future works, and it gives them the incentive to write more stories if they know that their hard work has been appreciated.  I am not saying that comments must all be lauditory.  Authors often appreciate honest, constructive criticism over simple remarks like 'Great story', although simple praise is appreciated also.  There is no limit on how much you can enter in the 'comments' box.   Sentences will automatically word wrap at the end of the line so please do not use your carriage return/enter key except at the end of your paragraphs.

      It is not necessary to use your real name here, and, email addresses are optional.  Posting your email address will allow the author to thank you for taking the time to post your comments, and/or discuss critiques and address possible concerns. 

      Be forewarned that abusive remarks and language will be removed, and the posters may be banned from this AND other areas of StorySite.



Name :
E-Mail : (Optional & Confidential)
Comments :
 
  

Please report any problems to Crystal