Crystal's Story Site
·
Return to Story Index Page
·
Add your Comments
·
Story Comments by Readers
Girlish
Latest comments are shown at top of page. |
Comment by Tom Linus on 09/01/23
Hi Karen. I haven't read your story yet, but I'm looking forward to it. I compiled all 12 parts into an e-book (epub format) just to make it easier for me to read on my tablet. I won't spread it around, it's just for my personal use. I was careful to keep the copyright notice, of course. Comment by Soniya on 11/07/13 Hi Karen, Comment by julieh on 06/07/13 great story to astart with partsone to three are very intresting look forwards to seeing how this pans out Comment by Buy oem Software on 02/11/12 1onP9H Develop the topic further! It is interesting to know more details..!! Comment by FRANKIE on 01/05/12 Wonderful! Comment by Leia on 12/05/11 I love this story series, have re-read it a few times now. It makes me feel good. Very well written, I always cry at the end thinking of Steffie and Brenda together. And yes, I too love forced feminization stories. Comment by TGV on 08/18/11 i have just one thought about this guy Comment by Mandy on 05/22/09 So many negative comments. It is fiction people. Sure some of the punishment is extreme but other than that it is pretty well written. I love forced feminization and these are the type of situations that push my buttons. Well done. Comment by Donna on 05/03/09 I enjoyed the story. It was interesting fantasy. Your heart could not help but go out to both Stephen and Brenda. I was a bit disturbed by the cruelty of Jill and Aaron towards Stephen. Comment by Neil on 01/13/09 This is an absolutely fantastic story. Definitely the best TG story that I've read. I had serious doubts about the level/violence of the forcing, especially in that it was a group of people ganging up on S. But the Brenda aspect made it interestingly different and compelling, and I'm glad that I stayed with it. This story makes a strong case for an exception to the rule that the end cannot justify the means. Comment by Jesse on 12/29/08 Idk if u still look here but in my mind that was the best storie on this site. Please keep writing. Ur stories r awesome. It was nice to have a happy ending 4 once. Comment by kuly CZ on 12/28/08 Ahoj, asi to nebudeš èíst ale musím Ti napsat, že tato povídka Girlish,je naprosto unikátní a nádherná. Dìkuji za požitek Jirka Comment by Dianna on 08/13/08 There is suspended disbelief and then there's...this. Better then some of your other work. Marginally. Comment by CATHY ANGELA DAVIS on 07/23/08 I STILL THINKS IT IS A CRUEL STORY, WHAT HAPPEN TO STEPHEN IT WOULD OF BEEN BETTER IF HE STAYED STEPHEN AND HELPED BRENDA THAT WAY AHD HE KNEW KUNG FU AND SAVED BRENDA BY BEATING THEIR HEADS IN, THIS IS NOT THE WAY TO HANDLE THIS SUBJECT. Comment by Yoron on 06/06/08 Another strange dream. Comment by TeddieBear on 04/18/07 One of the best stories I've read on this or fictionmania's site! Comment by jenny michaels on 01/27/07 You show excellent potential! There is enough to make the characters start to seem real. There is enough to stir strong feelings and emotions in the reader. The reader can actually begin to "take sides" as demonstrated by the comments. Comment by Sissy Baby Paula on 01/22/07 This one was hard to read. Well written and full of details - but... Comment by WannabeGinger on 01/19/07 Me again..... I've read to the end of the story and have to say that Chapter 11 should NEVER have been written - not believable, not well-written and adds nothing to the story..... You call this a love story, and there is a Chapter 12 "happy ending" but really, it's over the top on the violence and rapings and there's very little love. Poor Brenda - I thought she was going to do well but I think she should run away! Comment by WannabeGinger on 01/19/07 I've reached Chapter 8 and have run by the SM aspects because I, personally, don't find they add anything to the "forced fem" style.... what I wanted to comment on was the great pity that it's taken this long to get Stephie's hair into the story.... quite right.. it SHOULD have been something that was done much earlier.... the femininty that a beautifully dressed head of hair brings is unequalled....... I hope it's not dismissed in later chapters. If it is, I'll have wasted too much time! Nice theme, pity about the SM overdone and the beauty/hair under-done! Comment by skirtedboy on 01/18/07 Although I liked most of the story, you do need to clean up a couple points. When Stephanie gets the key from his mom, he never mentions giving it back. Comment by Joni on 01/18/07 First I want to appologize for not saying that as a writer, you did very well. The object to writing is to instill emotion in the reader, and that you have done. Comment by Jane Hudson on 01/18/07 I love the fact that he/she and Brenda got together and they both became stronger and love each other very much .No matter what other did to Steve he came out of this with honor even the bad guys in this story saw this .The worse persons in this is Ms Carter and Bart they are real !!!!. But Brenda and Steph found love with each other and they won out in the end. I Thought some parts were nasty but that made the ending and the love Brenda and Steph found even sweeter Comment by Jillmi on 01/17/07 Note to some who commented. Comment by Joni on 01/16/07 I am sorry, this story is truely masochistic in a very degenerative type of way. It started out alright sort of, but then the first spanking occured, I was sick. It wasn't a small spanking or a sensual spanking it was a BRUTAL spanking, one that would leave bruises. I serious stopped reading it for a while, it really disgusted me. I believe when the spanking occured and that Arron beat the snot out of Steven. It was abusive and very sadistic. It really turned my stomach and I had to stop reading. Comment by Jan Brown on 01/16/07 I enjoyed the story but also understand some of the other comments that there's no one likeable in the story. I am a voyager with the author and didn't expect some twists. I also know I would have had a very difficult time if this were to happen to me or anyone in my family. Thanks for the read and please post additional stories. Huggs, Jan Comment by katlo on 01/16/07 Great story..Thanks for sharing with us. Comment by Dick Dunham on 01/15/07 I finished the rest of the chapters. I normally wouldn't read a story that long but I thoroughly enjoyed it all..Dick Dunham Comment by V for vendetta on 01/14/07 You just need to add one line, about how Jill was killed by a micrometeorite as she sat there gloating about stealing Stephan's life.. Comment by publius on 01/14/07 The question I wonder at is WHY? Why does Jill want to do this? The wierdness of it becomes manifest when we see the types of allies she enlists: Aaron, Bart and Ms. Carter. Sociopaths all. What point does the author think he is exploring. Is the interest in this all reducible to self-hate? The mutilation which you are willing to enact on those characters you obviously identify with to some extent, makes it self-mutilation. Is this the extent of your ability to wonder about the sexes and their differences. My limit was reached with the second chapter introduced today when Jill is not satisfied after the date with Brenda and wants to really make him more girlish. Why? Make her state a reason. How does physically mutilating this boy satiate her self-loathing at being female. She seeks to force a male totem to undergo loss of manhood and gets those round hips, butt and breasts. Why? Here feel what it feels like??? Do you think that would make him "girlish"!!! You really have no idea about girlhood do you??? Do you see the ambivalence she [and you] have to all the femmy trappings? Are they punishment or reward? How crazy to suppose that girlish atitudes could result from Aaron's manical tortures? Adult women have a hard enough time at appearing girlish. Do you have even a clue about between the masculine and feminine psychology? Comment by Mikereader on 01/14/07 Very good story, and what a treat to have such a well written piece to entertain us. Look forward to seeing more from you Comment by moggicat64 on 01/13/07 i hope he turns around and kills the lot of them,they don't deserve to live Comment by Marcie Vickers on 01/11/07 Great Story. I am surprised you have not used the process called penile manipulation during his sexual relief time, which is when a dominant lady fondles the male parts of her submissive charge to arouse him and at the same time suggesting that the reason he is aroused is because he is loving the process of being feminized, when of course in fact he is aroused because the male organ is very sensitive to the human touch. Making such suggestions while arousing them does tend to cause a whole lot of confusion for the little darlings. Maybe when you introduce Steph to the joys of wearing makeup, you also add a little more joy to Steph's otherwise unhappy existence. Comment by Anita on 01/11/07 WOW. This is just great reading. I was mesmirized from the start and can't wait for the next installments. Comment by AmiLamida on 01/11/07 Absolutely the best story I have read in quite a while. Not all the fetishes are to my tastes (the cock restraint was a bit much), but who cares? The story and characters are fascinating! At first I was very skeptical of motivations, and I remain a bit skeptical of the whole broad acceptance of his transformation, as well as the fact that nobody sticks up for him at all, but hell - not everything has to be realistic! Comment by Jack on 01/10/07 Well done Karen, loved your story. I am in the process of searching for a subject to transform like the boi in your story. My profile, nowmymaster, telling about what I am looking for can be seen at collarme.com Comment by Vivien on 01/10/07 OOOOOOOOKay. I am so hooked and hope that sometime soon there will be more! One thing I hate is getting into a story and find that I have to wait to read either the end or a little more here and there so please, please, please hurry? It is a good story but like others I plead that there will be no more beatings! However, since he took the beating like he did and did not find a way to fight back or get even then I feel he deserves or needs to become a female. I hope though that there will be no more beatings? I know what it's like to be beaten unmercifully and believe me it is no fun! Comment by Linda C on 01/09/07 Fantastic story!! Definitely one of the types of love to see: forced fem. Comment by Laura on 01/09/07 Hi Karen, Comment by H Steves on 01/09/07 I love the story, cant wait for more. I like that he keeps resisting the changes. Comment by mayuri varma on 01/09/07 hi karen , i was desperately waiting to read this story, it was thr on u r website site but since u site is not working, i was desperate, Comment by tony on 01/08/07 Liked your story very much .. Comment by sezial on 01/08/07 Good plot idea, the problem I have with it is that it would be so easy for Steph to just walk out and go to the Principle or his Mum or anyone for that matter for help. What the story lacks is a solid reason to keep Steph on his path to feminisation. Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 01/08/07 There are no likable characters in this story. Jill and her friends are classic sadistic bullies who pick on a blameless person for their own amusement. But the worst bully is Ms. Carter an adult who is using her position of power to encourage the young bullies; what a disgrace to the education profession. Nobody gives a damn about Steve, he's just "the project". Even Brenda is only friends with him because they are making him what she wants; she knows he hates it and doesn't care. They all know he hates it and don't care. Are these people living in the United States? Nobody seems at all concerned that basic rights are being violated; they might as well have been brought up in Nazi Germany, as they certainly embrace the might makes right philosophy. But, then, even Steve is becoming less and less likable as well, as he simply puts up with it. Any enjoyment of the process of feminization is taken away by the despicable, heartless way in which it is being done. This story reminds me a lot of "Prom Princess" by Linda C over at Fictionmania. The character Karen in that story is a lot like Jill. Comment by Scrambler_J on 01/07/07 I picked this tale to start today having first notice it while looking for something else to read. I know...not a great praise there, but from chapter one I was HOOKED! Comment by Rita on 01/06/07 I think the pacing is just fine. And since this is a "love story" all will work out for the best. Just no more beatings please. Too much real violence in the world today. Comment by Dick Dunham on 01/06/07 I really enjoyed your story. Looking forward to the next chapters. Comment by Jane Hudson on 01/06/07 Fun story but maybe he and his mum might wise up and sue the guts of Jill and co any lawyer would love this case or would Jill have an ace up her sleave by getting him to write why I like being a girl as a get out of jail free card. I hope that Bredna and him become good friend and he dont do something silly but if he let himself go feminine and say I am me in a skirt or pants so there. but I like the story maybe the lawyer could get a cut of the new belt for him if it sells well. Comment by Zomba on 01/06/07 Your story is a real page-turner! I lke the way you haven't moved things too far too fast. That seems very realistic. I, too, would like to see Jill work on his level of obedience in things that are not related to his clothing a bit more before moving Steph into a more femine role, but you have been doing a great job thus far and have every confidence that you will continue to do a great job in the future. You are off to a great start. Comment by Barbara Jo on 01/06/07 I love the way this story is going so far. I'm really interested in seeing Stephanie want to change to look more feminine. You might say that a bit more prodding by Brenda or maybe even one of the boys she/he is attending classes with might help. Plant the seed and watch it grow. Comment by Valentine on 01/06/07 For someone who is supposed to be referring to Jill as Miss Jill, he never seems to do it. It is always just Jill. The story is good, but you might want to think about that. |
Add your Comments |
The importance of reader feedback cannot be overstated. Authors rely on it to improve their future works, and it gives them the incentive to write more stories if they know that their hard work has been appreciated. I am not saying that comments must all be lauditory. Authors often appreciate honest, constructive criticism over simple remarks like 'Great story', although simple praise is appreciated also. There is no limit on how much you can enter in the 'comments' box. Sentences will automatically word wrap at the end of the line so please do not use your carriage return/enter key except at the end of your paragraphs. It is not necessary to use your real name here, and, email addresses are optional. Posting your email address will allow the author to thank you for taking the time to post your comments, and/or discuss critiques and address possible concerns. Be forewarned that abusive remarks and language will be removed, and the posters may be banned from this AND other areas of StorySite. |
Please report any problems to Crystal