Crystal's Story Site
· Return to Story Index Page · Add your Comments ·

Story Comments by Readers

Marriage Renewal
by Elaine Grace

Latest comments are shown at top of page.


Comment by Kazuhiko on 01/06/13
Mrs. Goodin is one of those special peolpe who is trustworthy, honest, high moral turpitude and non-judgemental.  I respect her and will be voting for her if the absentee ballots arrive on time.  Thank you for speaking kindly about her.  We don't have to agree about everything with each other, but I do agree that Mrs. Goodin will be quite an asset to our Comanche Nation.

Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 11/11/08
I just reread this and I stand by my earlier comments. There is no real love here on Barbara's part, and Dr. Angel is no angel.  Ed trusted Barbara and she betrayed him, the trust was all one way.  Ed has no recourse against Dr. Angel because he was brainwashed as well as physically transformed, and "she" will "grow in love" as guaranteed by Dr. Devil because she programed him that way. Trust betrayed, rights violated, and false and artificial love.

Comment by chris on 05/28/06
part 3????come on do not leave us hanging

Comment by karen on 08/04/05
This may be the most thought through body swap story I have ever read, any plans on going forward?

Comment by Kammi on 12/14/04
I liked the story. Always hard to do mind/body swaps but I felt you pulled it off nicely. Liked the parts about hubby/wifes's reactions to hair being in curlers. Please keep them coming. Thanks for sharing with us.

Comment by Jean on 11/13/04
I am sorry but I would have told Barbra become Ed to take a hike for not being open with me before we the transformation. I might have considered the transformation if I had been told about it before. Just my opinion.

Comment by Jill M I on 11/13/04
Usually Jezzi is so supportive of other authors.

I think your story is very ambitious and so far you are fulfilling on those goals.

It is one of the best concepts I've read for quite some time, even though I usually don't bother with body swap stories as the premise is hard for me to swallow.

What I like most is the excellent effort you've made to get into Ed's mind.

Jill

Comment by Francine on 11/12/04
Hi Elaine,

It's your story hon, so you tell it how you want.
I'm not looking at the right or wrong, just the love that is there between two people. The love that makes it possible to forgive each other. There is no one that is perfect, we all make bad decisions.

Hugs, Fran

Comment by Stephan(ie) on 11/12/04
One last comment. Is the reason that Barbara(real) wanted the max in time due to the fact that she didn't want to go through menopause herself. So she let her husband go through for her, so when they changed back it would have been over with? If this is the case, then I would have to say that Barbara is very selfish and that as soon as they changed back then Ed should leave her!

Comment by Stephan(ie) on 11/12/04
I think it is a "sweet and sentimental" story. If it makes both Barbara and Ed that much better at understanding each others' needs then it is well worth it. It is true that Ed was tricked, but sometimes men have to be since it really isn't their nature to be the "caring and mothering" type. Men do tend to really not listen to what their wives have to say, so maybe trickery is needed for them to see and feel what it's like to be a woman. I hope the new Ed finds out what a man has to go through and comes to appreciate exactly what a man has to do. On the negative side though, I feel ten years as each other is way to long and over done, maybe a year or year and a half would have been more than enough. As adults I'm sure they both would have experienced exactly what each has to go through in the shorter time. On a personal note, I really look forward to their re-newing of the vows and the beautiful wedding gown that the new Barbara is going to be wearing. To this end I'm looking forward to their future adventures.

Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 11/12/04
<<  If you only knew what your mother has done to your father!  >>

I still don't understand how he can stay with a person who has changed him so without his knowledge or consent.  Even if he likes the change, the betrayal of trust would be, I would think, unforgivable.

Comment by joanna on 11/11/04
the second installment was quite understanding and tender.
there is a great feeling of intimacy; these two are finally becoming soul mates.

Comment by Renegade on 10/23/04
I am with Jezzi and Jenna.  This is NOT a "sweet and sentimental" story.,  Ed was tricked and now must spend ten years in his wife's body.  I hope that Barbara has a long, cold, period as Ed.  Sex?> Fortget it.  OH! Sottry, he has been braiswashed to be the dutiful little wife.  I hope he has enough will power left to poison her.

Renegade

Comment by Deidre on 10/09/04
One of the most thought provoking stories I have read in a long time, looking forward to the future chapters

Comment by Max on 09/26/04
Good sstart. I wwonder if more iss going on than iss aparament, I wonder how the neww Barb will do with HER daughteers. I one I suspect is thaat aaafteer 10 years the thought of going back wwith sseem foreign to both!

Comment by Paula on 09/24/04
I like how the story going and look forward to future chapters. It will be a joy to read. Do agree the change was a real trick on Dr. Angel part and Ten years a bit harsh.  Other similiar stories been no more than two years. We'll see how they make out

Comment by Jezzi Stewart on 09/23/04
Dr. Angel is no angel.
I agree with Jenna; it was a dirty trick, and Dr. Angel is no angel if she will do a switch like that without the consent of both parties.  If I was Ed/Barbara, in response to Barbara/Ed's statement "I don't want a divorce.", I'd say, "Well. I DO want a divorce; I may have to live 10 years as a woman, but I won't live them with you.  How could I ever trust you?"

Comment by jenna on 09/23/04
sort of a dirty trick. I don't think that's a good way to improve a marriage. More like end it. And why did she ask for the max time, I think she hope that they never switch back. Sorry time to pull the plug and take a bottle of pills.  I think this would be reasonable to offer a way out. Or at least I sure the lessons could be leand in a few months. TEn years later he will be completely brain washed and not know who hes was. Sorry sugur coated poison is still poison.

Comment by excitedlooker on 09/23/04
I enjoyed and am looking forward to the upcoming chapters.



Add your Comments

      The importance of reader feedback cannot be overstated.   Authors rely on it to improve their future works, and it gives them the incentive to write more stories if they know that their hard work has been appreciated.  I am not saying that comments must all be lauditory.  Authors often appreciate honest, constructive criticism over simple remarks like 'Great story', although simple praise is appreciated also.  There is no limit on how much you can enter in the 'comments' box.   Sentences will automatically word wrap at the end of the line so please do not use your carriage return/enter key except at the end of your paragraphs.

      It is not necessary to use your real name here, and, email addresses are optional.  Posting your email address will allow the author to thank you for taking the time to post your comments, and/or discuss critiques and address possible concerns. 

      Be forewarned that abusive remarks and language will be removed, and the posters may be banned from this AND other areas of StorySite.



Name :
E-Mail : (Optional & Confidential)
Comments :
 
  

Please report any problems to Crystal